collected
Once Upon a Broken Heart cover

Fiction · Novel · Speculative Fiction · Fantasy

Once Upon a Broken Heart

Stephanie Garber

First published 2021 · Once Upon a Broken Heart · Book 1

Reading facts

✓ Checked
Reading effort
25 / 100Light
Length
432 pagesFlatiron Books · 2023
Reading time
8 h 45 minat 50 pages an hour ·
Pace
Brisk
Emotional intensity
3 / 5
Heat
0 / 5SweetNo sexual scenes

Estimated from the page count of this edition. Dense books can take longer than the estimate.

About the book

In the magical city of Valenda, Evangeline Fox seeks help from Jacks, the immortal Prince of Hearts, to stop the boy she loves from marrying her stepsister. His price is three kisses, to be given at times and places of his choosing. Evangeline knows that immortals can honor their bargains while harming those they help, but her hope of winning Luc back outweighs her caution.

Reader notes

Dreamy and ornate, the prose lingers over magical surroundings and dangerous attraction. The romance in this YA fantasy series opener involves little sexual detail, and Evangeline's faith in true love repeatedly outruns her judgment. The elaborate descriptions can feel excessive, especially when the romantic uncertainty is already delaying answers.

How it reads

Writing style
Atmospheric · Descriptive
Tone
Atmospheric · Playful · Romantic · Tense
Structure
Linear
Driven by
Plot · Relationships · Worldbuilding
Point of view
Third person, limited

Reading complexity

Writing
2 / 5
Ideas
2 / 5
Structure
2 / 5
Background knowledge
1 / 5
About this profile

Collected’s assessment, not reader ratings. Complexity runs from 1 (least demanding) to 5 (most demanding).

Writing
How much attention the sentences and language require.
Ideas
How much interpretation or abstract reasoning the book asks of you.
Structure
How much you need to keep track of speakers, timelines and connections.
Background knowledge
Prior knowledge needed to follow the book, beyond what it explains.
Emotional intensity
Emotional pressure, from gentle (1) to intense (5). Separate from difficulty.

Themes

  • Love
  • Morality

Content notes

Violence
Mild
Sexual content
Mild
Swearing
None
Substance use
Mild
Abuse
Mild
Self-harm or suicide
Mild

Series and reading order

Once Upon a Broken Heart

  1. 1Once Upon a Broken Heart · This book · 2021
  2. 2The Ballad of Never After · 2022
  3. 3A Curse for True Love · 2023

Questions readers ask

Is it hard to read?

Not really, the story follows a linear path with a brisk pace. The prose is dreamy and ornate, though, lingering over magical surroundings in descriptions that can feel excessive.

Do I need to read the earlier books first?

No, this is the first entry in the Once Upon a Broken Heart series. It opens with Evangeline seeking help from Jacks, the immortal Prince of Hearts, and accepting his price of three kisses.

How spicy is the romance?

Sweet: no sex on the page. The romance centers on dangerous attraction and Evangeline’s faith in true love, with little sexual detail.

Will the romantic uncertainty get frustrating?

Evangeline’s hope of winning Luc back repeatedly outweighs her caution and judgment. Romantic uncertainty delays answers, and the elaborate descriptions can make that delay feel more pronounced despite the brisk pace.

How long is it?

About 432 pages in the Flatiron Books 2023 edition. The pace is brisk, though the prose lingers over magical surroundings and dangerous attraction.

Which edition is shown here?

Flatiron Books · 2023 · Paperback. ISBN 9781250268402.

How long does it take to read Once Upon a Broken Heart?

About 8 hours 45 minutes at 50 pages an hour, based on the 432-page Flatiron Books edition. Dense books can take longer.

About the author

Stephanie Garber

Stephanie Garber writes young adult fantasy romances built around seductive spectacles, binding bargains, and realities that refuse to stay fixed. Her plots move quickly through clues, curses, reversals, and concealed motives, while atmospheric, descriptive prose gives equal weight to magical settings and emotional stakes. Caraval establishes her characteristic method: a five-night, audience-participation game in which Scarlett must find her abducted sister, even though performance and magic make every perception suspect. The setup joins a puzzle-box structure to a story of sisterly protection and escape. In the interconnected Once Upon a Broken Heart trilogy, Garber shifts from staged competition to dangerous folklore. Evangeline Fox bargains with the immortal Prince of Hearts, and the precise price of three future kisses opens into a longer contest of trust, desire, and manipulation. The Ballad of Never After tightens that pattern through a murderous curse and a fragile alliance, keeping romance inseparable from mystery. Garber repeatedly turns wishes and promises into plot mechanisms, then tests her heroines through the terms they accepted.

Books by Stephanie Garber →

If you liked this

Midnight Sun cover

Midnight Sun

Stephenie Meyer

Speculative Fiction · Fantasy · Romance

Twilight cover

Twilight

Stephenie Meyer

Speculative Fiction · Fantasy · Romance

Fallen cover

Fallen

Lauren Kate

Fantasy · Romance · Young Adult

New Moon cover

New Moon

Stephenie Meyer

Fantasy · Romance · Young Adult

More by Stephanie Garber

Edition and details

Publisher
Flatiron Books
Publication year
2023
Format
Paperback
Pages
432
ISBN
9781250268402
Edition language
English
Original language
English
First published
2021
Genres and form
Fiction · Novel · Speculative Fiction · Fantasy · Romance · Young Adult · Paranormal romance · Mythic fantasy
Editions
15
Languages
4 (English, Spanish, Dutch, Unspecified)

Collected is coming to iPhone soon.

Keep your books, reading history and notes together.

We’ll send one email when the app launches, nothing else. You can unsubscribe.