Should I read Better Than the Movies first?
Yes, starting with Better Than the Movies gives context for Wes and Liz’s relationship. This sequel follows their reunion after he broke her heart, with lingering hurt shaping their second chance.

Fiction · Novel · Romance · Sports
About 9 h 15 min · at 30 minutes a day, about 19 days
Estimated from the page count of this edition. Dense books can take longer than the estimate.
At twenty, Wes Bennett returns to UCLA to restart his baseball career and reconnect with Liz Buxbaum, whose heart he broke after a family tragedy. Liz has built a college life without him and wants to concentrate on her filmmaking internship, but an assignment covering his team brings them together again. While Wes plans the grand romantic gestures she once loved, Liz tries to keep their history from interfering with her work.
Playful dialogue alternates with grief and lingering hurt in this YA second-chance romance, a sequel to Better Than the Movies. Both characters narrate, accompanied by movie quotations and music references. Sexual content is mild, though the language is strong; much of the emotional drama comes from Wes's persistence and Liz's resistance.
Collected’s assessment, not reader ratings. Complexity runs from 1 (least demanding) to 5 (most demanding).
Yes, starting with Better Than the Movies gives context for Wes and Liz’s relationship. This sequel follows their reunion after he broke her heart, with lingering hurt shaping their second chance.
Sweet: no sex on the page. Sexual content is mild, and the romance centers on Wes trying to reconnect through grand gestures while Liz resists letting their history interfere with her work.
Strong language is the main content concern. Grief after a family tragedy and lingering emotional hurt also shape the romance, while sexual content is mild.
Playful dialogue and romantic comedy alternate with grief, guilt, and lingering hurt. The tone is hopeful and humorous but also wistful, with much of the emotional drama coming from Wes’s persistence and Liz’s resistance.
No, the prose is conversational, witty, and driven by dialogue. Both characters narrate in first person, and the nonlinear structure is accompanied by movie quotations and music references.
464 pages in the Simon & Schuster Books For Young Readers 2025 trade paperback edition.
Simon & Schuster Books For Young Readers · 2025 · Trade Paperback. ISBN 9781665947145.
About 9 hours 15 minutes at 50 pages an hour, based on the 464-page Simon & Schuster Books For Young Readers edition. Dense books can take longer.
Lynn Painter writes contemporary romances for young adult and adult readers, using the machinery of romantic comedy with a clear awareness of its formulas. Her novels move through quick, conversational prose and dialogue-driven scenes, often turning banter, staged intimacy, and mistaken assumptions into engines of both pacing and character development. Painter repeatedly places people who want love to follow a recognizable script inside arrangements that make their own motives harder to read. In Better Than the Movies, a teenager steeped in romantic films recruits her antagonistic neighbor for a jealousy scheme, while grief for her screenwriter mother gives that movie-minded plotting emotional weight. The Do-Over literalizes revision through a Valentine’s Day time loop, letting repetition loosen its heroine’s attachment to a perfectly managed life. In the adult romance Mr. Wrong Number, alternating viewpoints and an anonymous text flirtation complicate an already charged shared household. Beneath the brisk comic setups, Painter returns to loss, family disruption, and old misunderstandings as pressures that shape what her characters expect from romance.
