collected
Identical cover

Fiction · Novel · Poetry · Young Adult

Identical

Ellen Hopkins

First published 2008

Reading facts

✓ Checked
Reading effort
46 / 100Moderate
Length
592 pagesMargaret K. McElderry Books · 2010
Reading time
11 h 45 minat 50 pages an hour ·
Pace
Variable
Emotional intensity
5 / 5

Estimated from the page count of this edition. Dense books can take longer than the estimate.

About the book

Sixteen-year-old identical twins Kaeleigh and Raeanne live in an affluent California neighborhood, where their judge father controls life at home while their politician mother campaigns. Kaeleigh tries to please the father who sexually abuses her; Raeanne resents his favoritism and seeks escape in painkillers, alcohol, and sex. Behind the family's public respectability, both struggle to cope without protection from either parent.

Reader notes

Told in alternating free-verse voices, the YA novel is intimate and emotionally punishing. Short confessional poems sometimes mirror one another visually, making their arrangement part of the reading. Sexual abuse, self-harm, eating disorders, and substance use are sustained subjects, described frankly.

How it reads

Writing style
Fragmentary · Poetic · Spare
Tone
Dark · Intimate · Tense · Unsettling
Structure
Braided · Fragmented
Driven by
Character · Relationships · Voice
Point of view
First person · Multiple viewpoints
Setting
California

Reading complexity

Writing
2 / 5
Ideas
3 / 5
Structure
4 / 5
Background knowledge
1 / 5
About this profile

Collected’s assessment, not reader ratings. Complexity runs from 1 (least demanding) to 5 (most demanding).

Writing
How much attention the sentences and language require.
Ideas
How much interpretation or abstract reasoning the book asks of you.
Structure
How much you need to keep track of speakers, timelines and connections.
Background knowledge
Prior knowledge needed to follow the book, beyond what it explains.
Emotional intensity
Emotional pressure, from gentle (1) to intense (5). Separate from difficulty.

Themes

  • Addiction
  • Family
  • Guilt
  • Identity
  • Survival
  • Trauma

Content notes

Violence
Strong
Sexual content
Strong
Swearing
Strong
Substance use
Strong
Abuse
Strong
Self-harm or suicide
Strong

Questions readers ask

Is it hard to read?

The spare language is accessible, but the alternating first-person voices and fragmented structure require attention. The greater challenge is emotional: the twins’ intimate accounts of abuse and coping are emotionally punishing.

What should I know about the disturbing content?

Strong sexual abuse is central, including a father’s sexual abuse of his daughter. Self-harm, eating disorders, and substance use are sustained subjects described frankly, alongside strong sexual content, violence, and language.

How does the verse affect the reading?

Short confessional poems alternate between Kaeleigh and Raeanne, bringing their voices close. Some poems mirror one another visually, so paying attention to their arrangement is part of following the narrative.

How long is it?

About 592 pages in the Margaret K. McElderry Books 2010 edition. The narrative takes the form of short free-verse poems rather than continuous prose.

Is it a good fit if I prefer character-focused stories?

Yes, the focus is on the twins’ voices, relationships, and attempts to cope within an abusive family. The dark, intimate narrative explores identity, guilt, addiction, trauma, and survival.

Which edition is shown here?

Margaret K. McElderry Books · 2010 · Trade Paperback. ISBN 9781416950066.

How long does it take to read Identical?

About 11 hours 45 minutes at 50 pages an hour, based on the 592-page Margaret K. McElderry Books edition. Dense books can take longer.

About the author

Ellen Hopkins

Ellen Hopkins is an American novelist best known for young adult stories told in free verse. Her pages use spare, fragmented lines, shifting arrangements, and sharply separated voices to compress experience and control pace. She returns to adolescents living under addiction, abuse, mental illness, sexual exploitation, and demanding families, with secrecy and divided identity often shaping the narrative as strongly as external events. In Crank, the split between Kristina and her bolder alter ego, Bree, gives methamphetamine addiction an internal grammar, while the changing verse layouts register compulsion and diminishing agency. Impulse moves among three teenagers in psychiatric care after suicide attempts, allowing their histories to emerge through alternating voices rather than a single account. Tricks expands that method to five narrators whose initially separate stories gradually converge. Hopkins began with nonfiction for children, but her verse novels established her characteristic scale: intimate voices set against pressures that accumulate through family conflict, coercion, grief, and unstable forms of belonging.

If you liked this

Sold cover

Sold

Patricia McCormick

Poetry · Young Adult · Survival

The Poet X cover

The Poet X

Elizabeth Acevedo

Poetry · Young Adult · Family

Wintergirls cover

Wintergirls

Laurie Halse Anderson

Young Adult · Family · Guilt

More by Ellen Hopkins

Edition and details

Publisher
Margaret K. McElderry Books
Publication year
2010
Format
Trade Paperback
Pages
592
ISBN
9781416950066
Edition language
English
Original language
English
First published
2008
Genres and form
Fiction · Novel · Poetry · Young Adult
Editions
4
Languages
2 (English, Unspecified)

Collected is coming to iPhone soon.

Keep your books, reading history and notes together.

We’ll send one email when the app launches, nothing else. You can unsubscribe.