collected
I Am Not Your Perfect Mexican Daughter cover

Fiction · Novel · Literary Fiction · Young Adult

I Am Not Your Perfect Mexican Daughter

Erika L. Sánchez

EstablishedNational Book Award finalist, 2017

First published 2017

Reading facts

✓ Checked
Reading effort
31 / 100Moderate
Length
368 pagesEmber · 2019
Reading time
7 h 15 minat 50 pages an hour ·
Pace
Moderate
Emotional intensity
4 / 5

Estimated from the page count of this edition. Dense books can take longer than the estimate.

About the book

Fifteen-year-old Julia Reyes wants to write and leave Chicago for college, ambitions at odds with her Mexican immigrant parents' expectations. After her older sister Olga dies in a traffic accident, Julia endures her mother's constant comparisons with the daughter who stayed home and followed the rules. Discoveries among Olga's belongings prompt Julia to question how well she knew her sister, even as she struggles to claim an independent life.

Reader notes

Julia's narration is blunt, angry and often funny, and her scathing judgments extend to people she loves. The YA coming-of-age novel combines family conflict and first love with grief and suicide; its emotional distress runs deeper than the search for answers about Olga.

How it reads

Writing style
Conversational · Direct · Witty
Tone
Dark · Earnest · Hopeful · Intimate
Structure
Linear
Driven by
Character · Relationships · Voice
Point of view
First person
Setting
Chicago · Mexico

Reading complexity

Writing
2 / 5
Ideas
3 / 5
Structure
2 / 5
Background knowledge
1 / 5
About this profile

Collected’s assessment, not reader ratings. Complexity runs from 1 (least demanding) to 5 (most demanding).

Writing
How much attention the sentences and language require.
Ideas
How much interpretation or abstract reasoning the book asks of you.
Structure
How much you need to keep track of speakers, timelines and connections.
Background knowledge
Prior knowledge needed to follow the book, beyond what it explains.
Emotional intensity
Emotional pressure, from gentle (1) to intense (5). Separate from difficulty.

Themes

  • Belonging
  • Coming of age
  • Family
  • Grief
  • Identity
  • Mental health

Content notes

Violence
Mild
Sexual content
Mild
Swearing
Strong
Substance use
Mild
Abuse
Mild
Self-harm or suicide
Strong

Standing and awards

Established

  • National Book Award finalist, 2017

Questions readers ask

Is it hard to read?

No, the prose is conversational and direct, and Julia tells her story in a linear first-person narrative. The greater challenge is emotional: family conflict, grief and suicide make the material heavier than the writing style.

What is Julia like as a narrator?

Julia is blunt, angry and often funny, with scathing judgments that extend to people she loves. Her desire to write and leave Chicago for college clashes with her Mexican immigrant parents’ expectations.

Is the mystery about her sister the main focus?

Not really, discoveries among Olga’s belongings prompt Julia to question how well she knew her sister, but the emphasis is on character and relationships. Julia’s grief, emotional distress and struggle for independence run deeper than the search for answers.

What difficult content should I expect?

Suicide and intense emotional distress are central concerns, alongside grief after Julia’s sister dies in a traffic accident. Strong language is also present, and Julia’s narration can be harsh toward the people she loves.

Who would it suit?

It suits someone looking for a YA coming-of-age story centered on a forceful voice, complicated family relationships and the pull toward independence. First love shares space with grief, mental health and questions of belonging.

How long is it?

368 pages in the Ember 2019 paperback edition.

Which edition is shown here?

Ember · 2019 · paperback. ISBN 9781524700515.

How long does it take to read I Am Not Your Perfect Mexican Daughter?

About 7 hours 15 minutes at 50 pages an hour, based on the 368-page Ember edition. Dense books can take longer.

About the author

Erika L. Sánchez

Erika L. Sánchez writes poetry, young-adult fiction, and personal nonfiction with close attention to image, rhythm, and the weight of individual words. Poetry supplies the technical base of her prose, while an acerbic conversational humor keeps difficult material in motion. Her work repeatedly examines borders, both physical boundaries and the social limits imposed on women of color. She moves between English and Spanish without routinely italicizing or translating Spanish, allowing context to carry bilingual thought. In I Am Not Your Perfect Mexican Daughter, Julia is angry, funny, vulnerable, and resistant to the demand that Latina girls be likable or exemplary. The novel makes conflict within an immigrant family reciprocal: teenager and parents misread one another, and sacrifice and protection can become guilt or repression. Chicago is part of that structure, as Julia’s movement through neighborhoods, transit, museums, and public spaces opens routes toward art and belonging. Crying in the Bathroom shifts the same candor into linked memoir essays whose separate shapes accumulate into a larger account of depression, work, womanhood, and motherhood.

If you liked this

The Outsiders cover

The Outsiders

S. E. Hinton

Literary Fiction · Young Adult · Literary fiction

The Hate U Give cover

The Hate U Give

Angie Thomas

Literary Fiction · Young Adult · Literary fiction

All American Boys cover

All American Boys

Jason Reynolds, Brendan Kiely

Literary Fiction · Young Adult · Literary fiction

Dear Martin cover

Dear Martin

Nic Stone

Literary Fiction · Young Adult · Literary fiction

Edition and details

Publisher
Ember
Publication year
2019
Format
paperback
Pages
368
ISBN
9781524700515
Edition language
English
Original language
English
First published
2017
Genres and form
Fiction · Novel · Literary Fiction · Young Adult · Literary fiction · Coming of age · Social novel
Editions
11
Languages
2 (English, Unspecified)

Collected is coming to iPhone soon.

Keep your books, reading history and notes together.

We’ll send one email when the app launches, nothing else. You can unsubscribe.